View Single Post
  #3  
Old 07-22-2014, 09:22 PM
bdcanetti bdcanetti is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Buffalo
Posts: 67
bdcanetti is on a distinguished road
Quote:
Originally Posted by ard View Post
Is your plan to buy a "leak diagnosis pump" and replace it???? To get rid of that code?

If I were faced with that code I would google the code, with "BMW" and read all I could...THEN I would come to understand that there are several things that can cause the DME to think it has a bad pump. ONE is a bad pump. Others are bad gas tank caps, and DTML solenoids...could be others.

Codes are not 'replace this part' instructions.... it just tells you were to start the diagnostics.

IMO
I have done a TON of reading on this from every Bimmer forum to the actual BMW service/repair manuals and the "common" cause is the pump itself.

My plan was to remove the pump and get power to it as a minimum to see if it's running.

I have already replaced the gas cap since it was cheap and easy.

Finally, I don't have the troubleshooting expertise but replacing a $70 pump as a shot at fixing it is a hell of a lot better than paying a mechanic at either the dealer or an Indy over $100 an hour in labor. I trust auto mechanics about as much as I trust....well...noone. I dont trust them. I've seen them bill people over and over again several hours on BS like front brake pad changes.

So long story short, I agree with you that I do my homework, make an educated guess and then start with the most probable and least expensive replacement options.
Reply With Quote

Sponsored Links