OH Crap! Hey Philip - a little help here??

[BigChar]

Hey Philip - I swear I had the best intentions this morning when I was cleaning dead bugs off my 2005 X5's grille with the windshield squegee at the gas station. Trouble is, I was a little under-caffinated at the moment and managed to put a nice hair-line scratch in my bumper! About three inches long, not horribly deep, but I can feel it when I run my fingers across it.

I have a PC7424 and some Einzett paint polish, but I think this may need a little more fixing than that can do. Thoughts or recommendations? I feel like a huge tool.