2006 X3 doors creaking problem

[simoncpw]

the upper part of the door frame (not on the door)... starting from the bottom of the A pillar all the way to the upper part of the end of the rear door

[byngsk]

Originally Posted by simoncpw

the upper part of the door frame (not on the door)... starting from the bottom of the A pillar all the way to the upper part of the end of the rear door

Thanks!! I'll go ask my dealer then.

[MysticBlueX3]

Originally Posted by B&DCalgary

And it's also well known that, although the 'official fix' is to replace the door seals, it doesn't work and the creaking noise comes back almost immediately.

Is is the door seals or the window seals or both? My dealer just replaced the 4 window seals.

[byngsk]

Originally Posted by MysticBlueX3

Is is the door seals or the window seals or both? My dealer just replaced the 4 window seals.

I think they replaced all the door seals and the window seals (seal on top of the door). But based on everybody's advice, it looks like it's coming from the window seal. right ?