Guys, I'm close to ditching the X5...

spaz07 · #1 05-11-2005, 08:00 PM

I'm thinking I'm not cut out for this X5 thing guys. In 6 months, we've had to replace an engine fan, water pump, coolant expansion tank, dsc module, and now it looks like 3 window regulators. Coming home tonight with my windows rolled down and the back passenger side wouldn't roll back up...I really don't know what to do but I'm soooo sick and tired of all these repairs and not to mention they're quickly adding up to some type of small trust fund in costs. Please don't take me wrong, the X was my first and DEFINATELY NOT my last BMW, but am I being a bit irrational here?! I'm really lost and have no idea what to do...please help!

-Zach

Anyone want a black 2001 4.4?

calvinx5 · #2 05-11-2005, 08:07 PM

mn......
my '01 X5 3.0 is also not reliable. I know how it feels.
You love the car but those random problems are the killers.

IMO, if I were you and with plenty of $$$, I would get a '05 X5. They should be much more reliable.
or maybe trade in for something else?

CalvinX5

Curious Joel · #3 05-11-2005, 08:13 PM

KEEP IT! or give it to me...

Honestly, though, it sounds like you have bad luck. I know it's not fun to have it in the shop all the time and it gets expensive, but you just need to weigh both sides.. Do you love it enough to not let troubles get you down, or are they too much? Personally, I'd keep it.. But do whatever's best for you.

spaz07 · #4 05-11-2005, 08:17 PM

Thanks for the quick responses guys. I'm just so frustrated, I wanna drive the damn thing off a cliff. I think all the repairs add up to close to $4000 in the past 6 months, not to mention we just bought $500 worth of pads and rotors. TALK SOME SENSE INTO ME!

-Zach

Curious Joel · #5 05-11-2005, 08:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spaz07

Thanks for the quick responses guys. I'm just so frustrated, I wanna drive the damn thing off a cliff. I think all the repairs add up to close to $4000 in the past 6 months, not to mention we just bought $500 worth of pads and rotors. TALK SOME SENSE INTO ME!

-Zach

I'd look for another X5.. You can get some pretty good deals and MOST X5's out there won't be as buggy as yours.. They've all got small problems, but some are just bad luck and everything goes wrong.

x5Monkey® · #6 05-11-2005, 08:24 PM

Normally I wouldn't tell anyone to get rid of their x, but there are a very few out there that are just incessantly buggy are best left for the next guy to deal with. It sounds like you might be the next guy in this case.
In my experience, I've had 2 x5's, the first 6 months of ownership will bring you to the dealership fairly often to work out some of the bugs, which isn't so bad when you're under warranty. But, after that time they've both been solid as a rock. Just a random problem once in a while.
If your's is a 2001 your big problems should've been fixed by now. Maybe wait to see if this round of repairs does the trick. If not, I'd try to find a new one. Just my opinion.

Quote:

Originally Posted by spaz07

I'm thinking I'm not cut out for this X5 thing guys. In 6 months, we've had to replace an engine fan, water pump, coolant expansion tank, dsc module, and now it looks like 3 window regulators. Coming home tonight with my windows rolled down and the back passenger side wouldn't roll back up...I really don't know what to do but I'm soooo sick and tired of all these repairs and not to mention they're quickly adding up to some type of small trust fund in costs. Please don't take me wrong, the X was my first and DEFINATELY NOT my last BMW, but am I being a bit irrational here?! I'm really lost and have no idea what to do...please help!

-Zach

Anyone want a black 2001 4.4?

Chris F. · #7 05-11-2005, 08:40 PM

I agree. Give it another month. If you are having more problems, sell it and call it a day.

BMWX5 · #8 05-14-2005, 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris F.

I agree. Give it another month. If you are having more problems, sell it and call it a day.

I agree

LeMansX5 · #9 05-11-2005, 08:45 PM

I had a 2001 X5 and did not have any major issues. Seems like you are having a bad time. I think you should move on to post-2003 model X5. You will be happy with a newer model.

ATCX5 · #10 05-11-2005, 08:58 PM

Love the damn thing, but the repair costs have so totally turned me off I can't explain it.
The suggestion to go out and drop $55+K on a new one is beyond comprehension to me. If this vehicle cost this much to maintain at 50-60K, why would anyone believe that the newer ones are going to be any better?
How big is the demand for 2001 X5's?