Difference between door trim clip part numbers

[phathom]

I got my front windows tinted right after I got my X5 a few weeks ago. Ever since then my driver's door has rsttled and the trim is obviously loose. I didn't worry about it much as I thought a few clips might not be alligned right and I had to take it off anyway to replace the door handle carrier anyway.
Well I replaced the door handle carrier today and found out they had lost or broke about half the clips for the driver's door. I looked up the part number on realOEM so I could order the right clips to replace them.
I found two part numbers:
51418224768: Door Panel Clip with Seal Ring Natural
and
51418224781: Door Panel Clip With Seal Ring Gray

Are these the exact same thing, but just diffetent colored or is there a functional /quality diffefence in the two? I'm not sure how many of which I'm missing as half the clips are just gone and more are broken.