I love my X5 4.6is but...

[racelance]

it's time for a 4.8!

Anybody have any options you feel would be a better fit? Perhaps a Q7?

This car was used for my wife's daily driver, but she'd like something new. Give me your feedback on what you feel should be her next ride...



Thanks,

Lance

[killcrap]

i think your better off in the 4.6is, the 4.6is has the better transmission, the old m62tu motor feels faster than the n62 motor. i'd say facelift the front end. and upgrade the steering wheel and air bag.

[racelance]

Originally Posted by killcrap

i think your better off in the 4.6is, the 4.6is has the better transmission, the old m62tu motor feels faster than the n62 motor. i'd say facelift the front end. and upgrade the steering wheel and air bag.

Trust me, everytime I drive the 4.6 I always leave the car with a big grin on my face. My wife is ready for a newer ride so I guess that's the angle we're going to go... I'm looking for alternative SUV's now - any other recommendations? It took me a long time to find the 4.6 I wanted (with the silver accents inside)... Maybe I'll have another talk with the wifey about reconsidering. Providing the reserve doesn't get hit.

Lance

[killcrap]

Is it really worth the change?

Facelift Front End with Adaptive Bi-Xenon Head Lamps
Seat Material
Trim
Panoramic Sunroof
N62 Engine with X-Drive, and TPM
Crystal Tail Lamps
SCA trunk
BMW Assist

i'm sure i'm leaving out some other things, but if i had the 4.6is i would just keep it and upgrade it.

[ZsX5o3]

If it's newness you're after I think the 4.8is may be a good choice. It definately feels newer. The ride is better, the steering feels sharper, and overall it feels more comfortable (especially if you get comfort seats, since I notice you have sports now).

I like the e70 for what they were able to accomplish handling wise with such a large vehicle, but it's hard to ignore how much larger it feels. It feels a bit like riding in a 1st class airplane to me.

Never driven the Q7 so I can't comment on that, but a low mileage 4.8is is still very much a player in the new used car market.

[FSETH]

I know my wife and if she is tired of her car, a face lift and steering wheel just wouldn't cut it.

I would ssay an e70 or a Q5.

You can always try to talk her into waiting for a brand spanking new X1 or X3, but I guess it depends on how many people in your family and how much cargo room you need.

[Trustyblonde]

Bummer that the wife is tired of the X5, I test drove EVERYTHING possible and there was only one that I liked. Obviously the X5. I am keeping mine till it dies or starts to kill the checkbook. I even drove a new diesel and still just love my older one. I drove the Audi Q7 and the smaller new Audi SUV, since I had an Audi vert before I got my X5 and they are ok, but something about the X5 that I just cannot pinpoint, just love it.

My husband is onboard with your wife, he would ditch his in a second he wants an Audi S5.

[racelance]

I'm torn... like I said I'm not certain I want to get rid of it b/c I really enjoy driving it. I love the pep and of course I love the look of it... Any other options out there? Thanks for your help!

Lance

[chilliwilli]

Have you tested the X6...preferably the 50i TT? Range Rover Sport SC is a bit heavier but is quite capable. There are plenty of sufficient alternatives out there...you just have to do the research and test them for yourself (and the Mrs. )

[c4racer]

How about a Cayenne Turbo? 3 year old models can be had for under 50% of new pricing - great value for a killer SUV. I personally do not think 4.6is to 4.8is is enough of a change, but maybe have her drive a few and see what she thinks. The ML550 is another one to consider.