Problem starting, is it the starter?

[Greg]

I own a 2001 X5 4.4 and I am now seeing problems starting her. It seems like the starter is just not taking hold. I turn the key and the started clicks. I turn the key off and try again a few times and eventually it will start. I'm thinking I need to replace the starter. Any help is appreciated.

[JCL]

Starter, battery, battery connections....

Test the battery, then see how much the starter is drawing, before planning to replace it.

[Greg]

When I turn the key, the engine turns over and starts, but the starter still tries to start the engine.

[gitchies]

i have the same issue. but mine does not want to start again...once in awhile i turn the key....nothing...lights come on etc as it i had put key in II position..then turn it back and go to start gain, it starts fine...not sure if i should be concerned...fairly new battery, new alternator...i'll check on the starter that might have been replaced too..its an 02 with 47000miles

[JCL]

Originally Posted by gitchies

i have the same issue. but mine does not want to start again...once in awhile i turn the key....nothing...lights come on etc as it i had put key in II position..then turn it back and go to start gain, it starts fine...not sure if i should be concerned...fairly new battery, new alternator...i'll check on the starter that might have been replaced too..its an 02 with 47000miles

Sounds more like the ignition switch, not an uncommon problem.

[JCL]

Originally Posted by Greg

When I turn the key, the engine turns over and starts, but the starter still tries to start the engine.

This sounds like you are saying that the starter does not disengage after the engine has started. That is quite different than the description of the starter not functioning when you first try.

If the starter is hanging up, then yes, it sounds like the starter.

[gitchies]

yikes......i may have take it soon...its ok for now, but does get annoying every now and then....expensive?