alternator question

[blktoptrvl]

Originally Posted by Zulu95

Be careful where you buy the alternator. Most of the big automotive parts places use "remans" that seem to be little better than an old unit with a fresh coat of paint. I have been reading on the boards for years of people on their third or more replacement unit within a very few months of service. Go to a good online place that sells the real OEM alternator at discount (e. g. BAVAUTO) or go to a Bosch dealer. It may be more up front but sure saves a lot of headaches later. (It is your wife's vehicle, right!)
GL

I know you are not suggesting a BMW dealer replacement, but...

I went to BMW for a replacement alternator. They quoted me ~$1000. I didn't want to pay a ripoff price like that, but I was also in a hurry, so I decided that spending the 1K was better than my time.

When I got to the dealer I mentioned to them that "at least I will be getting a new alternator out of this..." To which I was told, "No, they are not new, they are remans only."

My point is that just because it is BMW doesn't necessarily mean quality. Are their reman procedures any better than anyone else's? I hope so, but you can never be sure.

[btmed]

the exact same valeo that was in the car but it is a reman, after getting back the $52 core charge, $178 plus tax..

[Big "J"]

Just replaced the alt. on the wife's 03 3.0i today. All good now......