Members report on Safety Defect in 2010 X5 35d

[Thunder22]

Originally Posted by tcfila

Are you always an a$$ or just here?

He's not being an ass, did you read the threads that prompted his comments?

[tcfila]

never mind

[ard]

Originally Posted by tcfila

never mind

We're cool

[ABMW]

There are some 15 individual members on this board, alone, within the first few pages of this forum who's vehicles have suffered from this issue. All of the vehicles have been 2009 or 2010 X5 35ds. There are more on Bimmerfest and other forums, which can easily be found. There are even more which can be found via google searches, and yahoo, which produce slightly different search results.

There are roughly 5 users, of this board, who have specific information regarding to this issue and have dealt with BMWNA in relation to it.

Some vehicles have self-corrected, some have been towed, and some have gone to the dealer to be returned with a "not able to duplicate" message. Some owners have had their vehicles replaced by BMW and some have sold them.

These are what are confined to the Internet alone. Logic dictates that only a handful of X5 owners participate on forums. Though, even if every single individual who's suffered this issue has posted their experience online, you'll again, find over 15 member on this board alone.

A search is simple to perform, so for those doubters please do so. ARD even in the face of facts, you continue do doubt Montoya? What is the point of doing so? Do you believe he's making the issue up, and taking is 35d into the shop during the first 150-miles simply to revisit his dealership?

Honestly? What gives you reason to doubt him, or what BMW is doing to correct the issue?

Have you a response?

[ard]

Originally Posted by ABMW

Some owners have had their vehicles replaced by BMW and some have sold them.

Name two. Internet name, user name, etc...and a link. One that has had their car replaced, one that has sold it for this reason.

And "going to trade it for a lexus" doesn't count. You clearly used past tense.

Edit: Craig, yes, I know.... ABMW has been using your impending trade as his sole datum for this assertion. And you are not trading it for the reason he says you are trading it.

[Craig]

Originally Posted by ard

Name two. Internet name, user name, etc...and a link. One that has had their car replaced, one that has sold it for this reason.

And "going to trade it for a lexus" doesn't count. You clearly used past tense.

I've never had the engine malfunction error. I've had enough other problems. Yes, I'm trading mine in for a Lexus...

Craig

[ABMW]

I've never mentioned Craig's name in any post whatsoever. ARD to be blunt, you're a liar. We'd all appreciate it, if you'd cease your behavior, at this point. No one finds this post to be humorous but you.

[soldmystang]

odd that an obvious "overt survivalist" would give up so soon.

i have no dog in this fight, but damn this is good stuff. McGruber!!!!!!

[soldmystang]

Originally Posted by Craig

I've never had the engine malfunction error. I've had enough other problems. Yes, I'm trading mine in for a Lexus...

Craig

YouTube - Lexus Possessed Steering Wheel

sure you wouldn't rather consider an Infiniti or maybe an Audi big guy?

[Quicksilver]

Well........
And here I thought you had a problem with personal attacks........

Originally Posted by ABMW

I've never mentioned Craig's name in any post whatsoever. ARD to be blunt, you're a liar. We'd all appreciate it, if you'd cease your behavior, at this point. No one finds this post to be humorous but you.