X5 vs New Porsche Cayenne

TheX5 · #1 05-17-2010, 02:50 AM

The 2011 Turbo sure looks nice. Lots and lots of great goodies. Starts out at 104K, and knowing Porsche it will be death by options.

Anyway, I was for sure getting another X5 until I did some more reading on the new Cayenne and now I'm not so sure...

What do you all think?

Sponsored Links

Roadster · #2 05-17-2010, 03:28 AM

I read a review of the new Cayenne last weekend and it seems to be outperformed by the X5 in regards to handling but I suppose the Turbo angine can make up for this

20C4S · #3 05-17-2010, 04:08 AM

i'm sure if u compare Cayenne Turbo to X5 of course the Cayenne Turbo is a better car. however, even a loaded X5M is still cheaper than Cayenne Turbo and a X5 35i & 50i will still be cheaper than Cayenne & Cayenne S. all comes down to ur budget i guess.

i was going to wait for the new Cayenne but we've been driving the Current Cayenne S & Turbo since 2004 so i'm going to try the X5 now. btw, u'll be able to get a good discount within a year on the new Cayenne then buying it fresh this summer. keep that in mind...

XXX555 · #4 05-17-2010, 07:29 AM

I don't appreciate how many parts are 'shared' between volkswagon and porsche....kind of like the toyota camry and lexus es 300 crap years ago. The Toureg and Camry benefit. Which brand/vehicle were those parts originally designed and built for and which quality standard?

Important to me also was the local Porsche stealor was a stick their thumb in your eye kind of service folks too.

Lastly, only from a certain angle, the pepper does not now look like a minivan utility vehicle.

hotrod2448 · #5 05-17-2010, 09:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 20C4S

i'm sure if u compare Cayenne Turbo to X5 of course the Cayenne Turbo is a better car. however, even a loaded X5M is still cheaper than Cayenne Turbo and a X5 35i & 50i will still be cheaper than Cayenne & Cayenne S. all comes down to ur budget i guess.

i was going to wait for the new Cayenne but we've been driving the Current Cayenne S & Turbo since 2004 so i'm going to try the X5 now. btw, u'll be able to get a good discount within a year on the new Cayenne then buying it fresh this summer. keep that in mind...

That. I've never been really impressed by the Cayenne unless it's fully optioned out and then the price tag is frightening and I still don't "get" the whole fast SUV thing. IMO I'd much rather have an X5M even though I'm still faced with the whole fast for a tank conundrum.

It does look better than the previous model but, I still don't love it.

santo · #6 05-17-2010, 10:13 AM

IMHO. No diesel? No Cayenne. It was not on my list of possibilities.

20C4S · #7 05-17-2010, 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hotrod2448

That. I've never been really impressed by the Cayenne unless it's fully optioned out and then the price tag is frightening and I still don't "get" the whole fast SUV thing. IMO I'd much rather have an X5M even though I'm still faced with the whole fast for a tank conundrum.

It does look better than the previous model but, I still don't love it.

Porsche have the stupidest list of options. yes when u loaded up a car the tag is scaring big, and yet when u're selling the car they're nearly worthless.

they make good cars, but they're being too cheap to their customers.

Roadster · #8 05-17-2010, 12:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by santo

IMHO. No diesel? No Cayenne. It was not on my list of possibilities.

We have the Cayene diesel here in Europe
it has the 3.0 TDI from the Audi Q7 at 240BHP and 550Nm of torque

not that impressive for a Porsche but it gets 'great' mpg...

TheX5 · #9 05-17-2010, 02:53 PM

My wife has a 2009 Cayenne GTS a few months back. It was pretty loaded, 3 months old, and with less thank 3K miles on it. Sticker was 95K, I picked it up for 70K. So I can personally attest to options not meaning squat on resale. On the other hand almost everthing on the Porsche is an option - I'm surprised it comes with a steering wheel as standard

Having said that I do like some of the available options on the Cayenne such as the heated windshield. I loved that feature on the Range Rover as it made a huge difference with snow/ice buildup when driving up to the mountains. Wish it was available on the X5.

I do prefer the iDrive to the Porsche PCM touchscreen - maybe I'm just used to it. And the X5's heads up display is awesome. And nothing but nothing bets the BMW multi-contour seats

I do wish the X5M came with 19inch all seasons as options (the 2011 Cayenne comes with them standard). I know they are no substitute for true snow tires, but they have been just fine for me on my 07 4.8i through some pretty nasty snowstorms, and certainly better than the huge 20 inch summer tires on the X5 M.

CarsRmyVICE · #10 05-19-2010, 05:40 PM

I pondered the same thing and have decided that it is not that I necessarily want a cayenne...i want something different! If I had a cayenne and the x5 was all new i would be tempted to get an x5. When laying out the cash to lease I feel the need to change vehicles, since that's what i am essentially paying to do. My porsche dealer is like a porcupine....small and full of pricks. On top of that i can not yet afford a cayenne turbo, which is the only one i realllllllly like. So....decision made.

Sponsored Links