Wheel replacement - 19 or 20?

[4MoJoe]

On the fence about either of these two options. One is the OEM 19" X5 rims and the other is a replica 20". Odd thing about the eBay auction it shows it doesn't fit my year even those his auction text say E70, E71...when you run the compatibility check it doesn't show it's compatible with 2010 or 2011 X5's or for grins I dropped in my 2004 and it wasn't either. Odd..

I've sent an email and haven't heard back in a day.

19"
Factory OE 19" 2011 BMW X5 Wheels Rims Set 4 New | eBay

20"
20" BMW 2011 X5 WHEELS RIMS E70 E71 X5 X6 - eBay (item 190545570071 end time Jun-26-11 03:23:16 PDT)

I like the 19"s and they are OEM. The 20's I'm on the fence about, I like the style, just thinking it might be too 'much'.

Anyone bought these 20's?

[ZuerstBMW]

I have a set of the 19" off my 2012 X5 I just got last week with the RFT 900 miles on them.
Might sell them. PM if interested.