Xoutpost.com

Xoutpost.com (https://xoutpost.com/forums.php)
-   X5 (E53) Forum (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e53-forum/)
-   -   Had the dealership look at my brakes (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e53-forum/23846-had-dealership-look-my-brakes.html)

SilverBullet 12-07-2006 03:13 AM

Had the dealership look at my brakes
 
I have a brake squeal that is becoming a growing problem. It started at as a slight squeak here and there, then you could hear more metal and metal contact. I had to dealership take a look at it, and they said that there was a lot of brake dust in the wheels, and so they put the brakes through a "burn" process where they made a few aggressive stops from 40 mph to 0 mph. They said that this would clean out the brake dust. However, lately my car has been squealing a lot more often. The squeal is louder, and occurs not only when I come to a complete stop, but also when I hit the brakes at other speeds, i.e. 40 mph, 60 mph. I also hear a louder metal to metal contact; It is a rough sound. I am not sure what I should do about this? The dealership said that there is 50% life on the brake pads. Is there somthing wrong with the rotors? Any suggestions and advice is greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.:)

supersteve 12-07-2006 09:02 AM

Before the "burn in" process will work the rotors should be scuffed with sandpaper on emory cloth. This needs to be done to break the glaze on the rotors for used brakes. It also needs to be done on new brakes to get all the rust inhibitor off the rotors.

The squeak is from the pads chattering in the calipers. Glazing is what causes chatter. The Burn in process puts brake material into the rotors to make them more effective. This makes the brake pressure less for the same braking effect. Less pressure = less heat = less glazing + brake dust.
The vehicle should not be allowed to stop during the burn in. This can cause the pads to leave a chunk of brake material on the rotors which gives a pulse in the pedal and/or steering wheel. if that happens your have to start all over.

To give you an answer. . .no the rotors are fine. They just need to be scuffed and burned in again.

SS

SilverBullet 12-07-2006 03:35 PM

Thanks. I am going back down to my dealership this weekend, and I will have them check the brakes out again, and suggest what you said.

supersteve 12-07-2006 03:50 PM

Anytime.

The Cleaner 12-07-2006 04:05 PM

Brake Burn in? That sounds like a terrible thing to do. Material transfer is a major cause of rotor hot spots. I would recommend you do not try to get pad material to transfer to the rotor. I can almost guarantee that will make your pedal pulse, your rotors cool less even and lower your braking capacity.

I did a Google search and no data came up for brake burn in. If I am wrong can someone please post a link that would endorse this process.

Thanks

supersteve 12-07-2006 04:37 PM

Cleaner,
you have mail.
It's a very common and needed thing to do.http://answers.yahoo.com/question/in...4133931AAjIqpW

The Cleaner 12-07-2006 05:05 PM

Thanks supersteve,

I am familiar with the brake bed in deals, They are not needed and almost impossible to reproduce with any consistence. TMD friction does not recommend it nor do any of the automakers. New car are also not subject to the process.

I know the web forums are full of different ways to break in brake pads, but honestly I have yet to see any major brake manufacturer, Auto Manufacturer or Dealership take part in the ritual.

noncom23 12-07-2006 05:09 PM

So just use the coating on exterior of the brakes? Or what else can you do
to stop the sqeal?

supersteve 12-07-2006 05:24 PM

Think about this. . .Do they want to sell you a lifelong part or do they want you to buy another set.

I can feel a difference in the brakes before and after burn in. It's something I have done for many years with no ill effects (other than the smell of burning brakes while doing it).

Think of it as a way to break in the pads in an accelerated and controlled way. Heat cool heat cool heat cool done. It prevents glazing which its the worst case senario for brakes.

Glazed brakes will wear at a highly accelerated rate because they are very ineffecient @ causing friction. This is especially true if the pads are chattering and/or squealing. The noise is the pads vibrating against the rotor. The vibration means they are not making full contact with the rotor @ all times. Less pad to rotor contact = increased pressure for same brake effect = increased wear = more money for the brake manufactures.

For light aircraft it is a required step, to burn in the brakes, after brake replacement. Same brake companies much higher liability.

Just my $.02

The Cleaner 12-07-2006 05:31 PM

Squeak is related to materials, very little else. A recurring squeak can be cured by changing the rotors and pads to OEM compounds, that’s Jurid pads in the front and Textar in the rear, a good Balo, ATE or Zimmerman rotor and 2 new caliper pins and the rubber bushing the pin rides in. Those pins and bushings can wear and cause the caliper to tilt and that is the likely cause if you are using the correct pads and rotors. BMW and TMD Friction spend hundreds of hours testing components to come up with the best blend. When consumers try to improve one area the result is a reduction in performance in another area.

Speaking from my experience, this is the best way to cure the problem, do not use any sprays or other snake oil when you install the pads, mount them dry and be 100% sure the pad shim is in place, that is your buffer between the brake pad “puck” and the caliper frame and piston. The shim will isolate the vibration to the rotor and pad friction surface and not let it transmit to the caliper where the squeak will develop.

supersteve 12-08-2006 11:06 PM

Check out this site. It's from Bosch but it explains why "The Cleaner" and I are both correct.

The first section talks about causes of noise. The third section talks about brake break in.

The Burn in I have been talking about is to cure the pads in a controlled way and apply some material to the rotors.

According to Bosch not all pads are created equal.

Enjoy the weekend (if you get one).


SS

supersteve 12-08-2006 11:07 PM

oops

supersteve 12-08-2006 11:07 PM

http://www.boschautoparts.com/Resour...s/BrakePad.htm


Double OOPS!

JCL 12-03-2010 03:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by andreasue (Post 785367)
Maybe that squeaking sound it the rust itself? Oh God i am always applying WD-40 on my breaks hoping to remove some rust. So tell me is it bad for my breaks? So far i am not hearing any squeaking sound in my car maybe because i maintained it with anti-rust spray.

Applying WD40, which is a water displacing product that includes mineral oil, to your brakes, is a very bad idea. Brake pads are not designed to be contaminated by oils and still have the proper performance characteristics (friction, durability, etc).

Squealing brakes are caused by the pad vibrating. You can isolate that vibration so that it doesn't carry through the caliper, when you hear it, by using high temperature grease on the ears of the pads where they touch the calipers. There should never be lubricant applied to the friction surface. Never.

apetrov1x5 12-03-2010 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JCL (Post 785369)
Applying WD40, which is a water displacing product that includes mineral oil, to your brakes, is a very bad idea. Brake pads are not designed to be contaminated by oils and still have the proper performance characteristics (friction, durability, etc).

Squealing brakes are caused by the pad vibrating. You can isolate that vibration so that it doesn't carry through the caliper, when you hear it, by using high temperature grease on the ears of the pads where they touch the calipers. There should never be lubricant applied to the friction surface. Never.

thank you, but what are the main causes of pad vibration?
I changed my rotors/pads (used ones) about 500 miles ago and the squelling is still there :(

JCL 12-03-2010 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by apetrov1x5 (Post 785388)
thank you, but what are the main causes of pad vibration?
I changed my rotors/pads (used ones) about 500 miles ago and the squelling is still there :(

  • Glazed pads (which have a different coefficient of friction than fresh pads)
  • Glazed rotors (same result)
  • Pads not installed properly (HT grease on pad ears, anti-rattle clips, etc)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:25 PM.

vBulletin, Copyright 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0
© 2017 Xoutpost.com. All rights reserved.