Xoutpost.com

Xoutpost.com (https://xoutpost.com/forums.php)
-   X5 (E70) Forum (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e70-forum/)
-   -   Is there any sign of a SIB for Excessive Battery Discharge? (https://xoutpost.com/bmw-sav-forums/x5-e70-forum/44026-there-any-sign-sib-excessive-battery-discharge.html)

Fredo 03-30-2010 03:13 PM

I've owned my car since Dec 2007, bought new.

Had no problems at all until last week when my wife went to start the car and the battery was beyond flat....no sign of life at all. Called out BMW Emergency Service who got the car started and said it sometimes happens that the car doesn't shut down properly. Anyway, we took the car for a good two hour drive to get some charge back in the battery and next day the warning about excess battery drain came up and the car really struggled to start.

The X5 went into my local dealer today, they've warned me it may take up to a week to find out what's wrong with it. Last X5 they had in with this issue took that long.

I will post more when I know it. In the meantime we will use our trusty VW Golf which despite the fact it's only done 2000 miles in 2 years and only gets used on short journeys has no problems with its battery at all!

Penguin 03-30-2010 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by emcman (Post 722054)
They do not have a good opinion of forums or people that post on them. They know just enough to be dangerous but do not know enough to offer anything really.


I can respect that position -- if THEY can figure it out and fix it without a lot of "false" fixes.


If not...

X5 Meister 03-30-2010 03:59 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Yeah this kind of thing seems to be becoming the norm. A friend of mine just bought a new 328i xDrive and on the window sticker one of the listed features is:

"Stronger electricity supply Included"


I'm amazed it wasn't an option that he was charged for!


Quote:

Originally Posted by Fredo (Post 727757)
I've owned my car since Dec 2007, bought new.

Had no problems at all until last week when my wife went to start the car and the battery was beyond flat....no sign of life at all. Called out BMW Emergency Service who got the car started and said it sometimes happens that the car doesn't shut down properly. Anyway, we took the car for a good two hour drive to get some charge back in the battery and next day the warning about excess battery drain came up and the car really struggled to start.

The X5 went into my local dealer today, they've warned me it may take up to a week to find out what's wrong with it. Last X5 they had in with this issue took that long.

I will post more when I know it. In the meantime we will use our trusty VW Golf which despite the fact it's only done 2000 miles in 2 years and only gets used on short journeys has no problems with its battery at all!


emcman 03-31-2010 10:16 AM

On mine X5 the last fix was a battery management cable change. Not sure what that is. They X5 will sit at the dealer a month or so and they will see what happens. In the mean time my trade assist X5 should be here next week. All in all two battery changes, a sunroof control module and the battery management cable are the parts I know they changed. Then a lot of talk about not shutting the X5 down properly with the comfort access. The drain is so sporadic but consistent they still are not sure it is fixed. I am sure it will all end up is some service procedure.

X-cellent 04-01-2010 02:47 PM

Well, on 2/24/10 my 2008 4.8 died for the first time (the computer told on me, yes I opened the doors too many times without starting the car over that weekend...:rolleyes:) and a full charge and i was up and running, till last week. I went away for a three day trip, left the car at the airport and all was fine when i returned....till i had to move the car that night...battery was weak starting it...then the next morning....dead...took over an hour for the car to start with jumpers from another car it was sooooo dead...anyway, I blew off all the warning lights and figured, let it blow up or whatever, after 20 minutes thay all went away...drove 340 miles monday and then again yesterday, so well see...think i'd better buy a portable booster for this next business trip..five days away is sure to make the car mad and not want to start.

Other than this issue, I love my SAV, but really, $75k to worry about leaving it for three days...c'mon!

Craig 04-01-2010 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X-cellent (Post 728425)
Well, on 2/24/10 my 2008 4.8 died for the first time (the computer told on me, yes I opened the doors too many times without starting the car over that weekend...:rolleyes:) and a full charge and i was up and running, till last week. I went away for a three day trip, left the car at the airport and all was fine when i returned....till i had to move the car that night...battery was weak starting it...then the next morning....dead...took over an hour for the car to start with jumpers from another car it was sooooo dead...anyway, I blew off all the warning lights and figured, let it blow up or whatever, after 20 minutes thay all went away...drove 340 miles monday and then again yesterday, so well see...think i'd better buy a portable booster for this next business trip..five days away is sure to make the car mad and not want to start.

Other than this issue, I love my SAV, but really, $75k to worry about leaving it for three days...c'mon!

That's why I got rid of mine. Two dealers and BMWNA said I need to use a battery tender every night. Total BS for a modern vehicle. No battery problems with my new Lexus GX 460 Premium.

Craig

emcman 04-13-2010 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 728447)
That's why I got rid of mine. Two dealers and BMWNA said I need to use a battery tender every night. Total BS for a modern vehicle. No battery problems with my new Lexus GX 460 Premium.

Craig

I love my X5 3.5D so far after one week and the price of zero was great. I even got $1000 in options thrown in for free. I did get a battery tender also free.

Now I see there is a sales hold by Lexus on the 460 due to slow stability control which is a roll over risk.

X5 Meister 04-13-2010 07:55 PM

You mean this car? Hmmm...

Consumer Reports isn't exactly TUV, and if it can't pass their test then... let's just say that trading in a Suzuki Samarai isn't really considered an upgrade.

http://www.xoutpost.com/off-topic/lo...60-unsafe.html

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 728447)
That's why I got rid of mine. Two dealers and BMWNA said I need to use a battery tender every night. Total BS for a modern vehicle. No battery problems with my new Lexus GX 460 Premium.

Craig


apw2607 04-13-2010 08:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X5 Meister (Post 732230)
You mean this car? Hmmm...

Consumer Reports isn't exactly TUV, and if it can't pass their test then... let's just say that trading in a Suzuki Samarai isn't really considered an upgrade.

http://www.xoutpost.com/off-topic/lo...60-unsafe.html

Oh .. but it gets much worse

The Associated Press: Toyota to temporarily halt sales of Lexus GX 460

EdmBimmer 04-14-2010 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 728447)
That's why I got rid of mine. Two dealers and BMWNA said I need to use a battery tender every night. Total BS for a modern vehicle. No battery problems with my new Lexus GX 460 Premium.

Craig

Dude,

Looks like Toyota stopped selling your Lexus.

BBC News - Toyota suspends US sales of Lexus GX 460

Be safe, and don't roll over.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:13 PM.

vBulletin, Copyright 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.0
© 2017 Xoutpost.com. All rights reserved.