Tire rack has one like this using BMW's. It just reinforced my decision many years ago to make it a practice to where season specific rubber

Good reads.

Just FYI-

The SIZE of the cars they use for 'comparison tests' can make a BIG difference. So unless you are shopping for 3 series tires, take the tirerack tests with a large grain of salt.

I put WAY more weight on feedback from actual owners of my car model.

A

The first time I hydroplaned on my Goodyear Eagles I never ever trusted them again in the slightest bit of rain. 4 of us could've been seriously hurt on the highway that day if not for the gravel near the off-ramp.

Driving on rubber as hard as rocks in winter is not the best thing to do. Sure it'll get you there but how much do you trust them?