Dilemma

[becLaguna]

Hi everyone.
I'm trying to make a decision about an X5 purchase and would be interested in some feedback.
I currently own a '02 X5 3.0 with 82,000 miles. I purchased it new and have enjoyed the ride . I am going to give my X5 to my 67 year old mother and buy something new (or newer).
I have been watching the the different models of cars and suv's on the market waiting to be inspired but nothing gets my attention like an X5. I still think it's one of the best all around vehicles on the road. I have seen a few photos and artist conceptions for the next generation X5 but I think I like the current model better.
So...I have been out shopping this week and it comes down to three vehicles.

1.) 2006 X5 3.0, silver/ black, prem., sport, rear climate, xenon, auto., mats. $51770 list. Can buy for $48,800 plus fees. I like the color

2.) new 2005 leftover (dealer received end of year money from the factory) 2005 X5 3.0, toledo blue/ truffle, prem. sport, rear climate, nav, xenon, auto. $52770 list. Dealer will include CD changer and sell for $44,900 plus fees. I like the equipment...not sure about the color

3.) used 2005 X5 4.4, silver/ black 10,000 miles, BMW certified w/ extended warranty, prem. sport, 19" wheels, auto. can buy for $45,000 -$46,000. This X5 looks and smells new. I like the way a 4.4 feels but am satisfied with a 3.0.

As you can see, all 3 are priced very close. #1 is where I'm leaning but #3 is less money and more... "X5". #2 seems like a good value but not sure about the color combo.

Your comments are appreciated!

Thank you

[BMW X5]

i would go for the 4.4 10k on that car is nothing and with the CPO and the extended warranty and color combo its a great deal i think. just to give you a comparison i bought a '02 4.4 black saphire metallic on black, with nav, sport, prem, winter, etc... for 37k + fees so for a 05 45k is probably a sweet deal

[vinuneuro]

Seems like a good dilemma to have; all three options are great. I say, forget about the first option, because all you're going to get with 2006 that you won't be the other two is the guage rings. While I think the Toledo blue/truffle color combo would be absolutely beautifuful, you've already had a 3.0, why not get yourself a 4.4 this time . If you look around, I'm sure you can find a great low milege 2005 4.4i with the options you want. Let us know which way you go.

btw, :xoutpost:

[statdoc]

Get the 4.4. Six cylinder vs. V8??

[TQ2K]

Go for the 4.4, almost same gas mileage as the 3.0 but has the extra power whenever you need it.

[Parker]

I would go for option #2. Great options, fantastic deal and a schwank color combo. V8 power is nice but the I6 is a sweetheart of an engine IMO.
No matter which one you choose in the end you won't be disappointed.

[ekaz]

Option 3 would be my pick. Won't regret getting the V8. Personally not fond of color combo on #2. Either way, all nice X's.

[JCL]

My first choice would be option 2, then option 1. The V8 would be my last choice, partly because it is not new and partly due to the V8 (the 70% of X5 purchasers who chose the I6 can't be wrong).

[Thunder22]

Originally Posted by JCL

My first choice would be option 2, then option 1. The V8 would be my last choice, partly because it is not new and partly due to the V8 (the 70% of X5 purchasers who chose the I6 can't be wrong).

70% of X5 owners are women who don't know nor care about the difference between the 6 and the 8

[X5Ghost]

Find a 4.8is, your decision would be much easier : )