This months Roundel

Wagner · #1 04-09-2007, 04:48 PM

This months issue features: X3 vs RDX and X5 vs MDX and as a bonus, X5 4.8 vs new Audi Q7.

Since that seems to be a popular topic on this board...for whatever reason...

So this should be even more reason for those of you that don't belong to BMWCCA to join. It is a member perk.

Here is a quick hit:

X3 was very surprising against the RDX.
X5 was at a loss to the handling of the new MDX as well as, to quote:

Quote:

Acura's previous MDX was nothing more then a warmed-over Honda Pilot. But the new machine, sporting an extremely capable and demonstratively effective all-wheel-drive system and a far livelier motor that offers better performance than its BMW competitor is much more vehicle---and at a price 25% less than the BMW, it represents not only a great value but a very compelling competitor indeed.

Q7 4.2 vs X5 4.8:

Quote:

Dynamically, the Q7 is a strong performer - but it doesn't quite match the power and handling package that the new X5 4.8i brings to the table. Despite its weight, the X5 feels noticeably more athletic than the Q7 and is more entertaining to drive quickly on a twisty stretch of road. ........
The only real advantage the Q7 has over the X5 is price and cargo room....

Sponsored Links

Michelle · #2 04-09-2007, 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WagnerX5

This months issue features: X3 vs RDX and X5 vs MDX and as a bonus, X5 4.8 vs new Audi Q7.

Since that seems to be a popular topic on this board...for whatever reason...

So this should be even more reason for those of you that don't belong to BMWCCA to join. It is a member perk.

SilverBullet · #3 04-09-2007, 04:57 PM

I just joined last week. Waiting to get all my info in the mail.

X5Jay · #4 04-09-2007, 05:42 PM

I was just reading those articles today. I don't understand the cover though - what is that supposed to mean?

motordavid · #5 04-09-2007, 06:59 PM

Got my copy today...the mail "service" sucks here in SW FLA;
very interesting read, imo. I realize it's one writer's opin,
but pretty fair handed and well wrote, methinks.

From my perspective, based on those comparos,
the X3 is worth the bucks over the Honda RDX, while
the new E70 may not be worth it over the new MDX.

I think Roundel is worth the price of admission for
belonging to BMW CCA, and I'm not nearly a BeamER
zealot; but, it's a very well done mag, imo.

Jay: "The Romantic Road"...the normal "cover designer"
was on vacay when this issue got put to bed.

BR,mD

AzNMpower32 · #6 04-09-2007, 07:16 PM

Yup, read the issue and the comparo. A few interesting notes I was surprised at

- I thought the opinions on the ride would be switched around. All the magazines I've read have complained about a stiff ride on the RDX and a more acceptable (tho by no means comfortable ride) on the X3.

- Didn't think the MDX would stand up so well, even perhaps beat the X5 3.0si when you factor in price differential. Man I almost don't want to admit it, but the X5 3.0si really doesnt seem to live up to its price tag. Maybe they shouldn't have tried to Americanize it and make it big..........just my opinion (waiting to be flamed by E70 owners).

X5FX · #7 04-09-2007, 09:00 PM

if your on a budget get the MDX...one thing these reviews fail to consider is the fact that the X5 is in a completly different league. The MDX is butt-ugly. When you see it on the road do you say "thats a nice looking ride?", not unless your eyeglasses need updating. Then when you get inside and are faced with the dozens of lights and buttons, does this really impress you?

The X5 is in another class...if you cant afford it, too bad...get the MDX.

Wagner · #8 04-09-2007, 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X5FX

..if you cant afford it, too bad...get the MDX.

And that is why people think Bimmer owners are d_cks.

motordavid · #9 04-09-2007, 09:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X5FX

if your on a budget get the MDX...one thing these reviews fail to consider is the fact that the X5 is in a completly different league. The MDX is butt-ugly. When you see it on the road do you say "thats a nice looking ride?", not unless your eyeglasses need updating. Then when you get inside and are faced with the dozens of lights and buttons, does this really impress you?

The X5 is in another class...if you cant afford it, too bad...get the MDX.

Not to arm wrestle...I don't have, nor do I plan on getting an MDX; but,
with that logic, all the Roller drivers have the greatest 4 door sedan on
the planet.

I like Xs: X3s, X5s, new X5s, but the art. points out that against the
3.0, that MDX is a helluva buy.

I love cars & Scoots: I have a hard time "seeing them" when I'm driving/riding them, however.

B&DCalgary · #10 04-09-2007, 09:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WagnerX5

Here is a quick hit:

X3 was very surprising against the RDX.

Any quotes from the article? You kind of left us hanging with a statement but didn't elaborate with a quote.

Sponsored Links