Transmissions Manual vs Automatic

[Daka]

I am trying to justify buying a Manual transmission X5
I'm driving a 99 528iTA (wagon) now...I looked for a manual when I bought it but they are VERY rare.
I enjoy shifting gears....strange as that may seem, ...I'm retired...don't have any schedules...no rush...generally not a lot of traffic here in Ft Lauderdale so...how many of you guys have the same feeling?
What percentage do you think are manuals?

[jigaro]

Originally Posted by Daka

I am trying to justify buying a Manual transmission X5
I'm driving a 99 528iTA (wagon) now...I looked for a manual when I bought it but they are VERY rare.
I enjoy shifting gears....strange as that may seem, ...I'm retired...don't have any schedules...no rush...generally not a lot of traffic here in Ft Lauderdale so...how many of you guys have the same feeling?
What percentage do you think are manuals?

In my view, manuals are rear, and manual X5's tnd to be less loaded then automatic, big percentage of manual x5's don't even come with climate controle.
I think they even stopped making them after 01, so for you to find one will be hard, and if you do it might have a lot of miles, way more then industry average.
Thats just my view, I RECOMMEND GET A TIPTRONIC AUTOMATIC

[NJ04e53]

I got a 04 6 spd locally here in NJ. They are rare. I love manual trannys but If I could get an automatic now I would. I had a good deal for it that's why I bought it.

[jigaro]

Originally Posted by NJ04e53

I got a 04 6 spd locally here in NJ. They are rare. I love manual trannys but If I could get an automatic now I would. I had a good deal for it that's why I bought it.

wow that is in fact rare, especially facelift, porsche has lot of them in GTS models but thats about all i have heard about manual suv's

[motordavid]

Daka,
As I've posted to you before, they are rare but findable, imo.
The 6 Spd replaced the non-overdrive 5 speed in ~'04, and
offers much reduced rpms at highway speeds.

Our '01 5 speed is simple to drive and I like that it's different,
though the high speed cruise rpms may be a determent after
the 100K+ mile range, in terms of engine wear.

My wildazzguess is that a couple % of the older Xs were 5 speed
manuals, and about the same for the 6 speed version. I would also
guess that the X3 6 speeds enjoy more adoption, but still probably
in the single digit percentages.

For fun, I clicked on BMW NA CPO car finder and put in manual trans
X5 request. I got the following back, but no idea if they really are
manual transmission models, as the Search also returned a long list
of '07s which did not have a manual option, that I recall.
NEway, good luck on the hunt; if you do find one on a Stlr's lot, the
bargaining power is on your side, imo.
GL,mD

BMW NA CPO Search:
http://www.bmwusa.com/Standard/Conte...delSearch.aspx





Certified Pre-Owned
Overview
Certification
Warranty
BMW Roadside Assistance
Financing
Special Offers

Inventory Search
Find a Dealer
BMW Members
Sign in
Model Search * Click here for more details
You can narrow your search by body style, series, price, transmission or distance from your ZIP code. Make your selections below and click search. Body Style
X5 Sports Activity Vehicle (SAV)

Transmission Manual
Zip Code
Distance No Limit
Search Search Results 134 vehicles found. To view details about a specific vehicle, click the model name.
Join the Certified Pre-Owned waiting list
1-100 of 134 resultsListings Per Page 10 25 50 100 Next Model Year Gearbox Miles Color Price Center / City /State Distance

X5 3.0i SAV 2004 Manual 43,824 Sterling Gray Metallic $21,979.00 BMW of Columbia
Columbia, SC

EDIT: I checked the listing below, out at the Fields BMW site and they
do show it as for sale and as a manual, fwiw:
http://www.fieldsbmwnorthfield.com/u...seHistory=true

X5 3.0i SAV 2005 Manual 31,755 Titanium Silver Metallic $28,995.00 Fields BMW
Northfield, IL

X5 3.0i SAV 2005 Manual 46,731 Olivin Green Metallic $24,995.00 BMW of Bridgeport
Bridgeport, CT

X5 3.0i SAV 2006 Manual 36,597 Kalahari Beige Metallic $29,995.00 Vista Motor Company
Coconut Creek, FL

X5 3.0i SAV 2006 Manual 46,898 Toledo Blue Metallic $29,900.00 Suntrup West County BMW
Manchester, MO

[lo_jack]

All you need to do is search 'transmission replacement' (or 'blown', or something similar) to justify getting a manual transmission, if that is what you are aiming for...those threads are all about autos. I'd go for the 6 speed, as motordavid said the cruise RPMs are high in the 5speed on the highway, and I would hope the ratios were a little closer when they added a gear.

[ZsX5o3]

Originally Posted by jigaro

In my view, manuals are rear, and manual X5's tnd to be less loaded then automatic, big percentage of manual x5's don't even come with climate controle.
I think they even stopped making them after 01, so for you to find one will be hard, and if you do it might have a lot of miles, way more then industry average.
Thats just my view, I RECOMMEND GET A TIPTRONIC AUTOMATIC

What jigaro means when he says "don't even come with climate controle" is they can often be found without Premium package, which includes leather(leatherette replaces it), wood trim, and electronic climate control (you get manual dials instead).

Like mD said if it's in your price range go for the '04+ 6 Speed.

[NJ04e53]

Originally Posted by ZsX5o3

What jigaro means when he says "don't even come with climate controle" is they can often be found without Premium package, which includes leather(leatherette replaces it), wood trim, and electronic climate control (you get manual dials instead).

Like mD said if it's in your price range go for the '04+ 6 Speed.

I guess I got one without the "climate control" - I have manual knobs. However, I have the leather and a piano black trim.

[ZsX5o3]

are you sure you have leather?

[Daka]

Good info guys...I'm still convinced to get a Manual
By the way, when you list manual in search on Autotrader etc, you get a lot of AutoMANUALS...need to look at the pictures of the dash !!